Two Immediate things in Need of Change
by Vijay Anand
So it all seems to be coming together. Entrepreneurship is not such an alien concept anymore, there are more and more universities imparting entrepreneurship as a logical career choice, there is enough knowledge base, and support organizations that are there to help entrepreneurs, the media seems receptive to the notion of new enterprises, the economy and policies are gearing towards spurring its growth, and the investment community realizes that India is a big enough market that they are open to tweaking the funding models that they are used to. Change is not an easy thing, and thats happening.
Is Entrepreneurship mainstream in India yet? No. When will it? Well, when you see these two things change.
1. Stop Expecting Free Handouts.
Listen, I do contribute a lot to the startup community and I can say so. I have hours to show forth and I am proud to be part of it. But You might not want to expect that as a norm. Everyone has reasons why they do the things they do. Mine – eventually I do want to get into investing, advising and turning around companies as a career, and it helps to be part of building the foundation of the ecosystem.
All that said, time is limited. And anything that is limited is expensive. So if you are going to ask someone to spend time with you on a periodic basis, and also put the mental energy, pull connections etc, then you are going to have to compensate them – doesnt have to be in cash, can also be in equity, but beer simply isnt going to cut it
(I’ve gotten plenty of beer offers, and so do plenty of folks i’ve talked to)
Think about it: You are going to build an enterprise that makes you your own boss (atleast for a while), lets you pursue your passion, and if all goes well will make you filthy rich. Tell me again why you are asking for my time in free? Karma doesnt cut it. There are plenty of NGOs that could return better Karma points.
There is also a more solid financial reasoning behind it. Every enterprise has to be calculated on the basis of inputs vs outputs and the value creation is the difference between the two. Economical break-even point is just one metric out of this calculation. What is also important to measure is every bit of input that goes into creating this value – otherwise you are going to end up with a skewed equation which can misrepresent the actual value that you are creating – what is not accounted for and leads to positive returns is no different than a subsidized model. So if you really want to measure the effectiveness of your venture and have a standing chance for when the market really shows its teeth at you, build it right, and measure everything possible right from the beginning. Account for it, and ensure that the model still holds.
So when will Entrepreneurship become mainstream? When there evolves a model to fairly compensate the support structures that are required to support entrepreneurs – that goes not only for Mentors and Advisors, but also for lawyers, Accountants etc.
2. Get out of Weekend Entrepreneurship Mode.
Have you noticed how everything related to entrepreneurship happens during the weekends in India? Why is that? Are we trying to accomodate students and people who are in day jobs to be part of it? If so, that answers your question as to whats the state of entrepreneurship in India – it means most folks are part-time, and so is the landscape as a whole.
I hate quoting silicon valley examples, but I was curious to notice how many events across the globe – (flipping through the Calendar of Somewhat Frank) that most startup events in Mature ecosystems happen during the weekday. Infact when I was in the valley, I was surprised to note that most of the startup events DIDNT happen during the weekend – except for ones where you build products over a weekend.
If startups are mainstream, and if entrepreneurship is an actual way of life, then it has to function as any other profession, right? Makes perfect sense to me.
In my mind, till these two are in place, starting up isnt mainstream Yet.
Excellent points, Vijay. Definitely people need to get out of FREE mode and expecting ecosystem will do things for me attitudes.
The weekday events thing is cultural more than anything. In the US almost all events happen during the week (not just startup events). Most people leave work punctually at 5, head home and then go to a meetup, user group, whatever during the week. They get sponsored to attend conferences. It’s all considered part of work. The weekend is left free to do their own personal things.
Out here, everything that happens out of office is considered personal work. Good luck leaving work at 4:30 to attend a meetup or user group. So all the events end up on the weekends.
@Siddharta:
Thats exactly my point. We dont have enough of an “entrepreneurial” base to build events for them, instead we have to accomodate the professionals in other walks of life.
A guy running a startup, and if an event is beneficial, will make the time to be part of it.
And a good chunk of companies do support the professional from going to events and accounting it as part of work. Have seen quite a few registrations like that happen for Proto.in on the first day of the event (friday)
@Vijay R: Absolutely agree.
Bigger events do happen during the week. Nasscom Emergeout, TiE events & Proto.in fall in this category, and they all happen on weekdays (partially at least).
Its the casual events, user groups & meetups that I was talking about that need to be on the weekend (these events would also happen during the week in the US).
Two of those, TiE and NASSCOM – I doubt are startup centric. Am involved with both of them, and even the thinking inside is not to target startups.
Proto.in – I know for a fact that we never aimed it to be a weekday event -it just accidental venue availabilities pushed us to making it friday/saturday.
What else is left?
We also need a heck of a lot more events.
Dear Vijay,
Entrepreneurs all over the world look for free “handouts”.
It is somehow something the world has accepted.
Doesn’t mean you have to give it to them, but even here in Silicon Valley, and most certainly elsewhere, people constantly approach me for my time “for free”.
Other than my strategy roundtables, where I do give ~an hour for free every Thursday at 8am Pacific, I turn them down.
But if you look at how many people ask, it is an interesting dynamic, for sure.
Don’t expect it to change
Sramana
Was this triggered by the discussion in LinkedIn about mentoring?
*******
The second point is closer to heart. As Siddharth says the bigger events do happen on weekdays, its the smaller meetups and less formal events that happen on weekdays.
I don’t see much wrong with that. People like us who are hedging our bets by working part time would certainly prefer weekend meetups. India still has a very conservative culture where “failing” at a startup is still looked down upon.
Weekend meetups makes the transition of India’s entrepreneurs/entrepreneurship culture easier.
Sramana: Oh, absolutely. I even advise startups that its a skill to see how far you can stretch your penny and free handouts and being cheap is part of it. Unfortunately not all professional help will come for free and the wisdom is in knowing the difference between the two. I know plenty of folks (both in the valley and in India) who’d gladly spend an hour or two over coffee to help things out – both parties mutually benefit out of such conversations. But if it is a regular affair and if there is thinking, and “skin” involved, yep its important that a model evolves around getting people’s interest covered.
Ankit: Dont know about personal pain point, but I do see a lot of amazing guys with experience not “wasting” time anymore, and thats bad for the overall ecosystem. I have a day job that pays my expenses and I’m always happy to meet with people (with its own limitations ofcourse)
I didnt mean to say that events should not be inclusive of those hedging their bets. I only meant to say that there arent enough full-time entrepreneurs and hence the reason all events more or less end up being in weekends to ensure there is some participation. You probably misunderstood it.
That said, “mutual funds” for invented for those wanting to be safe. Not entrepreneurship. Its really not for everyone, and its just sad to even try to accomodate that, in my opinion.
Manu: Partly that, partly a conversation that is going on in a city about setting up an angel network and they expect mentors to spend “few hours every week” – and it made me laugh
@Aniket:
Hehe. Good luck “Converting”. If you are expecting entrepreneurship to become the next religion, it wont. And trust me, no one apart from the entrepreneur himself has the greatest benefit to make the leap. Take it or leave it. Really!
And i didnt say that the transitioners should be sidelined, but eventually once the entrepreneur population rises, there can be events just for them – or maybe there already is a good enough size and they just dont want to bump into too many wannabes. Quite possible.
hi,
Your post is interesting but just wondering why everyone would compare India with the USA or any other country for that matter.. India is the most unique example to the world.. we were one of those first countries who was trading spices with other countries way back 500AD. After Mughal raj it probably got spoiled even more during British raj. Otherwise you will find small or big entrepreneurs in every walks of life.. Secondly, I have never seen young turks asking for any kind of funding in other industries compare to IT businesses.. pls share your views about the Indian way of doing business and why IT and media guys need to go out to get the funds..
thanks
Vaishali Shah
http://www.vaishalishah.wordpress.com
ww